One Chance to Be More Specific

In Omnia, the primary building block of character creation is the Ability, which is a vocation or avocation. Characters may start with one to four Abilities. If they start with fewer than four, they may add Abilities during gameplay. An Ability gives a character a wide swath of capabilities. If you possess the Ability of Musketeer, you are skilled at marksmanship, fencing, battlefield tactics, carousing, and any number of things that might pertain to being a musketeer or having a musketeer's experience. An Ability is not a general characteristic or attribute like Strength or Intelligence or Dexterity, although an Ability might be indicative of a character's inherent characteristics. A character's rating as a Musketeer might very well indicate an equivalent level of agility and dexterity (especially if you make your character a Dextrous Musketeer or an Agile Musketeer). Attributes, in other words, can be inferred from a character's Abilities and used as such with moderator approval.

The problem is that some gamers will ignore this fundamental fact of the game and resort to listing their Abilities as common attributes instead of occupations. I cannot stop people from doing this, but I can offer this insight: If you list an Ability as being an attribute such as Dexterity or Charisma, it will deprive your character of skills and knowledge. You may be generally dextrous or charismatic, but anyone who is, for example, a Pianist or a Game Show Host can already use their Abilities of dexterity and charisma respectively in general terms, but they also have skills, knowledge, and connections associated with those Abilities. You are only depriving your character of competence when you focus on general characteristics.

If a player insists on using run-of-the-mill generic attributes as their Abilities, I, as a moderator, will just mentally substitute a generic avocation. Your Ability is not Intelligence 3. You are a Generally Intelligent Person 3. Your Ability is not Strength 5. You are a Generally Strong Person 5. You will be able to test your Abilities generally like anyone with an applicable Ability, but you will lose any tie against a character with a more specific Ability, and you will never be able to use such Abilities to achieve tasks that are the province of dedicated vocations or avocations. For that, you can only use Luck (with moderator approval).

Abilities are so much more powerful than attributes. Lean into it.